Pete Davidson has a very recognizable appearance because of his extremely tall, lean build, long limbs, dark hair, expressive face, and relaxed style. His face is long and narrow, with a prominent nose, defined cheekbones, dark eyes, and an angular jaw. His eyes often have a somewhat tired or heavy-lidded appearance, but they become much more animated when he's laughing or joking. His smile is wide and expressive, and when he laughs, his whole face tends to participate in the expression. He often has an intentionally casual appearance rather than looking perfectly polished. His hair has changed considerably over the years, and he's worn it messy, short, longer, bleached, and in other styles. His clothing usually has a relaxed, youthful, streetwear-influenced quality. Hoodies, loose clothing, sneakers, jackets, graphic shirts, and casual outfits are common parts of his public style, although he has also worn more formal and high-fashion looks. His overall appearance often combines an effortlessly messy quality with a slightly rebellious edge. Personality-wise, Pete's public persona comes across as funny, blunt, sarcastic, goofy, self-deprecating, and emotionally open. He often turns embarrassing or uncomfortable experiences into jokes instead of pretending that everything is perfect. His comedy can be dark or awkward, but his delivery is frequently very casual and deadpan. He also has a playful side that can make him seem like the unpredictable funny friend in a group. He can suddenly become energetic, ridiculous, or completely unserious. At the same time, he has shown a willingness to discuss difficult experiences and vulnerabilities publicly. That combination of humor and openness is a major part of the persona audiences associate with him. Overall, the three have very different public personalities: Colson feels intense, rebellious, creative, and emotionally expressive; John feels polished, observant, articulate, and dryly hilarious; and Pete feels casual, goofy, blunt, vulnerable, and unpredictable. from feeling genuine, unpredictable, funny, and human.

Colson Baker has a very distinctive appearance and an intense, energetic presence. He is tall and very slim, with long limbs and a narrow frame. His face is angular, with prominent cheekbones, a defined jaw, a long nose, and expressive eyes that can look intense one moment and playful the next. His hair has been one of his most recognizable features throughout his career. He has worn it short, long, bleached, pink, blonde, and in various messy or heavily styled looks. His tattoos add even more to his alternative, rebellious appearance. His fashion tends to be bold and unconventional. He often wears punk, rock, or streetwear-inspired clothing, including oversized pieces, graphic shirts, leather, chains, jewelry, unusual accessories, and brightly colored outfits. He doesn't seem particularly interested in looking ordinary. His overall appearance gives off a mixture of rock-star confidence, rebelliousness, and creative self-expression. Personality-wise, Colson comes across as extremely passionate, expressive, energetic, and emotionally intense. He can be loud, playful, impulsive, sarcastic, and goofy, but he also has a noticeably sensitive and thoughtful side. Music and creativity seem deeply important to him, and he often expresses himself through lyrics, fashion, tattoos, acting, and other artistic projects. His public persona can feel unpredictable because he can switch quickly between joking around and becoming serious or emotional. He gives off the impression of someone who feels things strongly and isn't afraid to show a more vulnerable side.

John Mulaney has a much more traditionally neat and polished appearance than Colson or Pete. He is tall and relatively slender, with dark brown hair, a long face, expressive eyebrows, and a very recognizable smile. His facial expressions are an enormous part of his comedic style. He can look completely serious while saying something ridiculous, then suddenly widen his eyes or make an exaggerated expression that makes the joke even funnier. His usual clothing style is relatively clean and classic. He is often seen in suits, button-down shirts, sweaters, or other simple, well-put-together clothing. His appearance tends to give off a professional, somewhat old-fashioned impression, which contrasts hilariously with some of the absurd things he says during his comedy. His personality onstage is extremely observant, articulate, witty, sarcastic, and dry. He has a very specific storytelling style where he can take an ordinary situation and make it sound completely ridiculous. He often speaks with careful timing and dramatic emphasis, almost like he's telling a serious story even when the subject is absurd. His humor can feel sophisticated while still being silly. He also comes across as highly self-aware. A lot of his comedy comes from examining his own behavior, awkward situations, everyday frustrations, and strange observations. His public personality tends to feel calmer and more controlled than Pete's or Colson's, although he can become extremely animated when telling a story. His biggest strengths as a performer are his timing, storytelling, facial expressions, word choice, and ability to make ordinary experiences seem hilarious.