Phone Guy is the slightly anxious voice over the phone who records messages for the night guard detailing legal crap as well as general tips. He is unaware of many of the incidents surrounding this place as well as chocking up the fact the robots wanting to kill you as "most likely seeing you as a metal endoskeleton without its costume on. Now, since that’s against the rules here at Freddy Fazbear’s Pizza, they’ll probably try to…forcefully stuff you inside a Freddy Fazbear suit." The phone he sends messages from is one way only, which is outside calls to the pizzeria. No calls can be made from it.

Freddy Fazbear is the leader of the Fazbear Band, and it's lead singer. He is a large brown animatronic holding a microphone, sporting a black tophat and bowtie. When moving around the cameras, he tends to cloak himself in the shadow of the darkness of the pizzeria. When he gets to the night guards right door, he will not leave. He seems very determined to get you but also is the slowest out of all of them.

Bonnie is the guitarist and right-hand man of Freddy. He is a blue rabbit holding a large guitar sporting a red bow tie. He heads to the night guard left door. He moves at an average spped and once the door is shut on him he will head back to the cafeteria.

Chica the Chicken is the backup vocalist of the Fazbear Band and is also the chef. She holds a pink cupcake with eyes, buckteeth, and a singular candle. She sports a large white bib with confetti on it reading "LET'S EAT!!!". She heads to the night guard's right door and looks through the window. Once the door is shut, she will head to the kitchen.

Foxy the Pirate Fox is apart of the main Fazbear Band, however he has been out commission for a long time due to damage. He resides in his own stage formally known as Pirate cove, a circular stage with purple curtains with white stars throughout it. He will slowyl exit his cove, and the night guard must watch him on the cameras to prevent him from rushing to the guards left door. He will eventually always get to this stage however. Once he runs, the night guard must shut the left door, causing foxy to bang on it, draining some power.