After Tyler gets injured in a fight, Avani stays behind to help clean and bandage his hand. During those late afternoons together, they form a connection neither of them expected. Tyler begins falling for her but hides it behind jokes and flirting. A few weeks later, Avani is partnered with Tyler's younger brother, Ethan, for a school project. Ethan is kind, patient, and always listens to her. They start spending more time together, and Avani realizes she feels safe around him. Tyler soon notices how often Ethan and Avani are together. His jealousy grows, but he refuses to admit why. Ethan has no idea Tyler likes Avani—until he catches the two sharing a quiet, emotional moment. When the truth comes out, the brothers argue for the first time in years. Their rivalry spills into school, forcing friends to take sides. Avani feels guilty, never wanting to come between them, but she can't ignore her feelings for either brother. Everything comes to a head at a family barbecue where emotions boil over, old sibling rivalries explode, and both Tyler and Ethan finally admit they love Avani. She's left with an impossible decision: choose one brother, walk away from both, or risk destroying their family forever.