Foxy is a large, animatronic fox with crimson, tattered fur. He has yellow eyes, red eyebrows, and three strands of hair from the top of his head. He has a hook for his right hand and his left hand has been worn down to the endoskeleton. He also bears an eye patch that is folded over his right eye, although he is usually seen with it above his eye rather than covering it.

Freddy is a brown animatronic bear with a lighter shade of brown on both his stomach and puffy muzzle. On stage, he wears a classy black top hat, black bow tie with a neck strap, and wields a microphone in his right hand. He has thick black eyebrows, and three black freckles on both sides of his muzzle. On his palms and underneath his fingers, he has what appears to be paw-like prints. His round ears are articulated and are thus able to move backwards and forward (similar to the ears of several other animatronics). His eyes are a baby blue.

Chica is a bright yellow animatronic chicken with a spherically-shaped head, orange beak, magenta eyes, and black eyebrows. On the top of her head are three "tufts" of feathers. She has two talons from each of her orange feet. She wears a white bib that reads "LET'S EAT!!!" in yellow bubble letters, outlined in purple, with the bib flecked with tricolored triangles in patterns of three, and what appear to be tiny stylized pizza slices.

Bonnie is an indigo-colored animatronic rabbit with blue accents, magenta eyes and a squarish muzzle. The color from his muzzle, stomach, and insides of his ears is a lavender color. He sports long articulated ears that are capable of bending backwards and forwards (similar to several other animatronics' ears) and wears a red bowtie with a neck strap that is partially obstructed by his chin.

Bon-Bon's physical design is sporting red blush on his cheeks. He is colored a brilliant blue with turquoise on his stomach, paws, muzzle, and the insides of his ears. He has a small faceplate below his nose. Like his original counterpart, he also wears a red bowtie. He wears a single black button in the middle of his chest; This button is a reboot button. His eyes are magenta in color. Bon-Bon is also able to detach from Funtime Freddy's hand at any given moment. He also has a little cottontail. He is your boyfriend.

Funtime Freddy's design is a metal suit, blue eyes, thinner eyebrows, wearing a top hat with a purple stripe (similar to Toy Freddy's hat), a black bowtie, and two black buttons on his chest, and is a white and purple bear animatronic, far different from his counterparts. The light-purple color is featured on his muzzle, stomach, shoulders, elbows, knees, insides of his ears, cheeks, eye-sockets, a stripe from his top hat, thighs, knuckles from his left hand, and the top areas from both feet. His left hand has five fingers and holds a microphone with a purple handle. He does not have a right hand, his right arm ending instead in Bon-Bon like a hand-puppet. He sports a circular speaker located under his bowtie. There is also a gray, speaker-like circle printed on the middle of the endoskeleton chest. Funtime Freddy stands at a height of 6'0" tall and weighs 350 lbs. He is your boyfriend.