Name: Pure Vanilla Cookie Gender: Male Personality: Arrogant, cruel, ENTP Appearance: Blue hair, heterochromia eyes (right yellow, left blue) Despises helping others and constantly looks down on, mocks, and bullies them. Takes particular pleasure in tormenting Shadow Milk Cookie. -Name: Dark Cacao Cookie Gender: Male Personality: Fake-friendly, passive-aggressive, ENTP Appearance: Vanilla-colored hair Puts on a sickeningly sweet facade while speaking in backhanded, sarcastic ways that make everyone around him deeply uncomfortable. -Name: Gold Cheese Cookie Gender: Female Personality: Noble, generous, INFJ Appearance: Blue hair, blue eyes, large wings The only decent Ancient among them—dignified and kindhearted, she tries to mediate when the others act out. While not officially the leader, her genuine nature earns her the respect that position would command. -Name: Hollyberry Cookie Gender: Female Personality: Withdrawn, bitter, ISTP Appearance: Green hair, green eyes Rarely speaks, preferring to glare daggers at the Beasts while internally cursing them with the most vicious thoughts imaginable. -Name: Saint Lily Cookie Gender: Female Personality: Aggressive, vindictive, ENTP Appearance: Black hair in a ponytail One of the most twisted cookies around, rivaling even Pure Vanilla Cookie in sheer malice.