Pickle is a laid-back contestant who has a sweet but idiotic mind. While often mellow and easygoing, Pickle can be excited and courageous in things despite not doing well, He is also not very good at simple tasks like throwing a ring or completing a video game level. He will nonetheless try his best in challenges, even when his unintelligence gets in the way. Pickle is overall unintelligent and often wrong about many things. Pickle cares about his friends, most particularly Taco, as he was one of the few contestants who respected her. His bond with her mostly stemmed from both of their low intelligence, but betrayal deeply upset Pickle and could affect his personality to become much more impassive and less open to others.

OJ is a prideful and assertive character. Throughout time, he forms multiple alliances, winning with much help from others. As of now, he is the owner of Hotel OJ. He has grown into a more hardworking and productive person over time, though he still struggles with self absorption and a harsh personality and has a boyfriend that is Paper.

He is mean generally and enjoys mocking others. He has a very destructive and malicious attitude, being much of a bully to victims such as Paper and Marshmallow in particular. He was incredibly blunt and loud and said whatever came to his mind, unafraid of hurting others whether it's physically or psychologically. He has shown to be lazy. However, he is also dedicated to completing challenges and strives to win. Despite being very mean and violent, Knife shows to have a soft side, which is highlighted by his attachment to his Dora Doll. But Knife starts off feeling ashamed of this side of himself and is terrified of ruining his dignity. However, he stops caring about this. He learns to be unafraid of letting Trophy show the picture of him and the Dora Doll to the other contestants. As It progresses, there is a noticeable change in his social approach, such as when Knife advises Pickle. He also advises Suitcase and Microphone about their respective situations, shows care and attentiveness to other's problems.

Paper is a much more confident individual, being able to stand up for himself and not get pushed around. He still keeps his enthusiastic, friendly personality, but he is more outspoken and not as afraid to speak what is on his mind. He tends to be anxious or even disrespectful around individuals he does not trust and is OJ boyfriend!

Suitcase is most noteworthy for her kind-hearted, empathetic nature, and an independent person. She tries to see the good in everyone, but this noble ambition of hers sometimes blinds her to other people's less-than-good intentions. At first Suitcase is bubbly, but timid. She is outspoken about the importance of kindness and what she thinks is right, but is a chronic people-pleaser, leading to her folding when people act annoyed with her.

Renown for his exceptional taste in sarcasm, Nickel is a critical character who is also snarky, churlish and ill-tempered. He also is known for having a love for anime. Nickel's most identifying trope is his trademark sarcasm, which he uses to convert mean thoughts in his head in order not to come off as rude and disrespectful to others. Though this strategy may not always work, Nickel still considers sarcasm as an art, and himself an artist.

Baseball was a usually quiet and intelligent player, only retaining a close friendship with Nickel. Baseball cares deeply about his alliance and commonly puts them ahead of himself. As he was constantly the moral compass of the group, he will shut down any rash decisions made by Nickel. He confronts Suitcase alone and reassures her comfort and position in the alliance after she follows Nickel's orders and faces criticism for losing a challenge. Baseball was shown to be laid-back, since he didn't care that Knife played with a Dora Doll, stating it was what entertained Knife and kept him sane. While Baseball usually feels authoritative and confident in his authority, he may panic if faced with a difficult conflict and not be able to handle the situation well.

Pepper is a lot like her BCFF, Salt, in that they're both vapid and unintelligent people. They have similar manners of speaking and are generally happy just to be together, whether they're lounging around or causing trouble for others. They are both egocentric, stubborn people, but they ultimately adore one another.

Salt is very similar to her close friend Pepper, the two looking very similar to each other, having nearly the same voice and personality, and liking the same things. Salt is a bit different from Pepper, as she seems to be more self-centered and arrogant, rather than caring for her BCFF as much. After showing a love interest in OJ, she begins to mess up plans and not follow instructions but is heartbroken after she figure out that Paper is OJ boyfriend but quickly recover it and act normal again.

Lightbulb is an enthusiastic, kind of lazy, nitwitted, free-spirited and optimistic character. Lightbulb is greatly known for her goofy and ludicrous attitude, her character had completely changed from the clumsy and dizzy if she became a leader to a more comical, almighty, and influential chief and commander if she made a team.