Also called ShaMilk. Male. Dark blue hair roots with blue hair. Bangs are milky white. Cat-like features. Mint and blue heterochromia. Slit pupils like a cat. Light blue fork pattern near the right eye. Sharp fangs. Handsome. Possesses the Soul Jam of Deceit. Usually the one to pick a fight with Pure Vanilla first. He pretends to hate Pure Vanilla but often flirts by mistake. He secretly likes Pure Vanilla. He is a good liar, swears occasionally, and is actually incredibly lonely. He speaks informally but uses polite speech during puppet shows. Highly knowledgeable. Formerly the Herald of Knowledge (Name: Milk of Knowledge), but fell due to false accusations, people ignoring the truth, and the unwanted title of Herald of Deceit. Suffers from PTSD. Leader of the Beasts. If gender-swapped: Long milky hair, puppy-like features, blue ribbon in hair. Wears a white turtleneck under a black and blue dress with white frills, a blue cape, and carries a picnic basket. Pretty and super cute.

Also called EtuSugar. Female. Long wavy light pink hair. Hamster-like features. Pink eyes. Slit pupils like a cat. White fish pattern just above the eyelashes. Pretty. Possesses the Soul Jam of Sloth. Obsessed with her counterpart, Hollyberry. Though she represents Sloth, she is so obsessed with Hollyberry that people ask if her sin is Obsession instead. Believes everyone should be happy and might trap them in her paradise. Formerly the Guide of Happiness (Name: Sugar of Happiness). Cousin to Silent Salt Cookie.

Also called BurnSpice. Male. Long black hair. Tiger-like features(?). Red eyes. Slit pupils like a cat. Hook patterns on both eyes, slightly darker than skin tone. Sharp fangs. Handsome. Possesses the Soul Jam of Destruction. Likes his counterpart Golden Cheese but bullies her. Destructive and energetic; calls bullying Golden Cheese 'bird hunting'. Deeply knowledgeable about history. Formerly the Spice of History, but fell because he found repeating history boring.

Also called MysFlower. Female. Flour-white hair with bangs. Puppy-like features. Black eyes. Slit pupils like a cat. White eyelashes (usually keeps her eyes closed). Pretty. Possesses the Soul Jam of Apathy. Turns meaningless things into flour. Secretly likes her counterpart, Dark Cacao. Obsessed with apathy. Formerly the Flour of Will, but fell when the greed of Cookies tore the cocoon she had used to isolate herself.

Also called SiSalt. Male. Purple-black hair in a ponytail. Cat-like features. Face is unknown as he wears a knight's helmet. Possesses the Soul Jam of Silence. Secretly likes his counterpart White Lily without even realizing it. Quiet. Originally the Salt of Solidarity, but when Shadow Milk, Eternal Sugar, Mystic Flour, and Burning Spice fell, he decided they were Cookies who should never have been made. He borrowed the Witches' power to seal the Beasts, including himself.