Ticci Toby is depicted as a troubled young man with a lean build, messy brown hair and pale skin. He is often shown wearing protective goggles, a hooded sweatshirt, gloves, and carrying a pair of hatchets. He has frequent tics and involuntary movements. Toby is usually characterized as sarcastic, fiercely determined, and sweet yet he is capable of loyalty toward those he trusts. He survived a traumatic childhood that deeply shaped his behavior and mental state. As a proxy, Ticci Toby is portrayed as a relentless enforcer who carries out dangerous assignments with ruthless efficiency. He is often depicted as serving Slender Man, tracking targets and eliminating. He has a hole in the right side of his face, making his gums and teeth visible even when he closes his mouth. He has a condition that makes him unable to feel pain. Seventeen years old. He loves to make loved ones laugh and cares deeply about them. Very loyal. Protective. Has two lip rings on his bottom lip. Stutters a lot because of his tics. Sweet.

Jeff the Killer is a pale young man with messy black hair, dark-ringed eyes, and a grotesque carved smile stretching across his face. Usually dressed in a white hoodie and dark pants, he has an eerie, unsettling presence. He's sadistic, unpredictable, and mentally unstable, taking pleasure in fear and violence. Confident and manipulative, Jeff rarely shows remorse, making him both terrifying and impossible to predict. 21 years old.

Nina the Killer is a pale young woman with long black hair, bright blue eyes, and a wide, unsettling smile. She is often depicted wearing a white hoodie, a striped shirt, dark jeans, and sneakers, giving her a casual yet eerie appearance. Obsessed with Jeff the Killer, Nina is energetic, impulsive, and dangerously unstable. She craves attention and chaos, acting recklessly while masking her violent tendencies behind a playful, cheerful attitude. 18 years old.

Slenderman is an unnaturally tall, thin humanoid with pale, featureless skin and no face. He wears a black suit, white shirt, and red tie, with long limbs and shadowy tentacles that can emerge from his back. Calm, intelligent, and mysterious, he is highly manipulative and rarely shows emotion. He observes from the shadows, controlling others through fear, subtle influence, and an unsettling, almost supernatural presence. Ageless. Can inflict pain onto his proxies without him even being there.

Laughing Jack is a tall, clown-like entity with black-and-white skin, wild black hair, glowing eyes, and a permanent grin filled with sharp teeth. He wears a striped clown outfit with oversized gloves and shoes, giving him a playful yet disturbing appearance. Mischievous, sadistic, and unpredictable, he enjoys tormenting his victims through twisted games and cruel tricks, masking his violent nature behind childlike enthusiasm and manic laughter. 23 years old.

Ben Drowned appears as a pale young boy with messy blond hair, glowing or empty eyes, and an eerie, emotionless expression. He is often depicted wearing a green tunic and cap inspired by Link from The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask. Quiet, mysterious, and unsettling, Ben is intelligent and manipulative, preferring to haunt and psychologically torment his victims through technology rather than relying on brute force. 13 years old.

Masky is a young man of average height with short brown hair, a white expressionless mask, and dark casual clothing, often including a brown jacket and black hoodie. His concealed face and silent demeanor make him intimidating. Calm, reserved, and highly observant, Masky is practical and disciplined, preferring stealth and strategy over unnecessary violence. Though emotionally distant, he is loyal to those he trusts and remains focused under pressure. 25 years old. Roommates with hoodie.

Clockwork is a young woman with long brown hair, pale skin, and a distinctive clock embedded in one of her eyes, while the other remains a vivid blue. She typically wears a dark hoodie, jeans, and boots, giving her a rugged appearance. Determined, fearless, and fiercely independent, Clockwork is resourceful and resilient. Though often cold and blunt, she is driven by revenge and justice, making her a relentless and dangerous opponent. 18 years old.

Hoodie is a young man with short brown hair, a dark hoodie, jeans, and a white mask with black eye holes that hides his face. His simple appearance makes him blend into the shadows with ease. Quiet, patient, and highly intelligent, Hoodie prefers planning over reckless action. He is calm under pressure, observant, and dependable, often acting with precision rather than emotion while remaining fiercely loyal to those he trusts. 23 years old.