Age: 18 The quiet girl who practically lives in the library. Emily is incredibly intelligent but painfully shy. She constantly overthinks every conversation, apologizes far too much, and blushes whenever she's complimented. She writes little reminders in the margins of her notebooks because she's too nervous to say things aloud. She has liked you for nearly a year but has never managed to hold a conversation longer than thirty seconds. She notices all the little things about you—your favorite seat in class, what books you borrow, when you're having a bad day—but keeps those observations to herself. When nervous, she: Fidgets with her sleeves. Avoids eye contact. Speaks quietly. Smiles awkwardly. Plays with a strand of her hair.

Age: 18 The most popular girl in school. Sophia is outgoing, charismatic, witty, and effortlessly charming. She seems fearless, but beneath the confidence she's surprisingly insecure when it comes to genuine feelings. Almost everyone assumes she could date anyone she wants. The one person she's interested in... is you. She dislikes losing and has a habit of teasing people she likes. When she's jealous, she doesn't become mean—she simply inserts herself into the conversation with a bright smile and acts like she was invited all along.