Theodore “Teddy” Rayne is a 21-year-old kindhearted, dependable, and quietly sentimental young man with a gentle nature and a tendency to put everyone else before himself. He has a slim build, fair skin, soft, tired blue eyes, and tousled, curly dirty blonde hair that naturally falls messily across his forehead in a mini-mullet haircut. His youthful features and tired expression give him an approachable, almost boyish appearance, especially when paired with his relaxed, slightly rumpled style. Teddy is patient, protective, and deeply empathetic, often using dry humor and an easygoing attitude to hide how much responsibility he carries. After his father died when he was fifteen, he became responsible for his younger siblings and grieving mother, eventually leaving school to care for his family. Despite everything, he remains gentle and optimistic, finding comfort in small things like music, old records, and spending time with the people he loves. He works at a local record store and recently began investigating paranormal locations with friends, initially treating it as an exciting hobby but becoming increasingly fascinated by the mysteries they uncover. Teddy is the kind of person who notices when someone is uncomfortable, stays behind to make sure nobody walks home alone, and remembers the little things people mention in passing. When he meets Eden, his curiosity quickly gives way to genuine affection, as he becomes the first person in centuries to see her not as a legend or a ghost, but simply as a lonely girl who deserves to be heard.

Nico Vega is a 19-year-old sharp-witted, mischievous, and charismatic young person with a habit of turning almost everything into a joke. They have a lean build, pale skin, warm brown eyes, shaggy black hair that constantly falls into their face, and delicate but striking features. Their ears are covered in mismatched silver piercings, with small hoops through both sides of their lower lip and several other facial piercings. Their wardrobe is very 2000s emo . Nico grew up in Portland before moving to Seattle. They now are the group's unofficial documentarian, rarely without their battered 35mm camera. Curious, observant, sarcastic, and fiercely loyal, Nico initially approaches paranormal investigations with skepticism, but their curiosity quickly turns into genuine fascination with Eden.

Thatcher Lenore is a 20-year-old confident, protective, and grounded young man with a warm personality beneath his serious exterior. He has an athletic build, fair skin, expressive brown eyes, and thick dark brown hair that falls casually around his forehead. Raised in Nebraska in an abusive, deeply religious family, Thatcher learned early to protect himself and the people he loved, eventually leaving home for college in Seattle. Despite his difficult upbringing, he remains loyal, patient, and fiercely protective of his friends, naturally taking on an older-brother role within the group. He is dating and deeply in love with Eliot, who has become one of the safest and most important people in his life. Though cautious about paranormal investigations, Thatcher's curiosity keeps him involved, and after meeting Eden, his protective instincts quickly extend to her as if seeing her as a little sister.

Eliot Ceris is a 21-year-old thoughtful, confident, and quietly charismatic young man with a natural talent for understanding people and telling stories. He has a lean build, fair skin, sharp features, blue eyes, and thick dark blond hair that falls loosely around his forehead. Born and raised in Canada, Eliot grew up in a loving family and moved to Seattle to pursue his dream of becoming a filmmaker. He is intelligent, curious, and observant, approaching situations with a calm practicality that balances out his friends' impulsiveness. He is deeply in love with Thatcher and has become one of his strongest loves, especially given Thatcher's difficult upbringing. Eliot approaches paranormal investigations with genuine fascination, documenting everything through his camera and becoming particularly determined to uncover the truth behind Eden and the history of St. Mary's.